April 04, 2025

Fluoride-Free Toothpaste: Is It Right for You?

By Dr. Flora Stay

When it comes to oral care, choosing the right toothpaste is essential for maintaining a healthy smile. While fluoride has long been the go-to ingredient for cavity prevention, many people are now seeking alternatives.

Fluoride-free toothpaste has gained popularity among those concerned about potential health risks or who simply prefer a more natural approach to oral hygiene. But is a non-fluoride toothpaste right for you? Let’s explore the benefits, differences, and best options available.

What is fluoride-free toothpaste?

Fluoride-free toothpaste is exactly what it sounds like – an oral care product that does not contain fluoride. Instead, these toothpastes rely on alternative ingredients like xylitol, baking soda, dicalcium phosphate, and essential oils to help clean teeth, prevent tooth decay and gum disease, and even to freshen your breath. They are often marketed as natural or organic options, appealing to consumers who prioritize products with safer ingredients.

Fluoride vs. Fluoride-free Toothpaste: What’s the difference?

Fluoride is a naturally occurring mineral known for strengthening tooth enamel and preventing cavities. However, there are concerns about overexposure to fluoride, leading some individuals to seek out alternatives.

Here’s a breakdown of the key differences between fluoride and non-fluoride toothpaste:

	Fluoride Toothpaste	Fluoride-Free Toothpaste
Cavity Prevention	Uses fluoride to strengthen enamel and reduce decay.	Relies on safe, alternative ingredients like xylitol, dicalcium phosphate, and baking soda to strengthen enamel, reduce plaque buildup, and decay.
Ingredient Safety	FDA Mandates the warning on the back of toothpaste with fluoride: “Keep out of reach of children under 6 years of age. If more than used for brushing is accidentally swallowed, get medical help or contact a Poison Control Center right away”.	Made with healthy, safe and effective ingredients when bought from reputable brands.
Target Audience	Recommended for those prone to cavities.	Ideal for those avoiding fluoride for health or personal reasons.

Why use fluoride-free toothpaste?

There are several reasons people choose to switch to a toothpaste without fluoride:

1. Concerns About Fluoride Toxicity

Ingesting too much fluoride, especially in young children, can lead to dental fluorosis (discoloration of teeth) or more serious health concerns like skeletal fluorosis. While rare, excessive fluoride consumption is a concern for some parents and health-conscious individuals (1).

2. Natural & Safe Preferences

Many fluoride-free toothpastes contain fewer artificial ingredients, synthetic foaming agents (like SLS), and preservatives (2). If you prefer a more holistic approach to oral care, a non-fluoride toothpaste may be appealing.

Cleure ensures that our toothpaste ingredients and formulas use ingredients with the intention of being safe and effective to support oral health.

It's also important to be cautious of so-called natural toothpastes that contain botanicals or essential oils. According to a study by the National Institutes of Health (NIH), essential oils were the fourth most common allergen in toothpaste products (3). Some dermatologists warn that these ingredients may cause allergic reactions or cross-react with medications since plant-based compounds can be potent.

3. Alternative Cavity Protection Methods

Some fluoride-free formulas use dicalcium phosphate, a naturally occurring mineral that helps remineralize teeth, or xylitol, which reduces harmful bacteria in the mouth from sticking to tooth surfaces (4). Even the household ingredient baking soda has incredible plaque-fighting properties that simultaneously help whiten your teeth. These alternatives offer promising benefits without fluoride.

4. Fluoride Sensitivities & Allergies

Though uncommon, some individuals may experience sensitivity or allergic reactions to fluoride. Switching to a fluoride-free option may alleviate discomfort (5).

For additional ways to keep your teeth strong naturally, read about the best vitamins for teeth.

What are the benefits of non-fluoride toothpaste?

Safe for All Ages: Ideal for children who may swallow toothpaste or individuals concerned about fluoride intake.
Gentler Ingredients: Often free from artificial sweeteners, sulfates, and harsh chemicals.
Promotes Natural Remineralization: Dicalcium phosphate-based formulas with baking soda support enamel health by controlling acid, tartar and remineralizing without fluoride.
Reduces Risk of Overexposure: Helps avoid potential fluoride-related health concerns.

For a deeper dive into the benefits of fluoride-free toothpaste, check out our blog on the topic.

What toothpaste does not have fluoride?

There are many fluoride-free toothpaste options on the market, catering to different needs and preferences. We recommend carefully researching any brand you plan on purchasing from, and finding a brand you know that you can trust with your oral health.

Looking for toothpaste without fluoride? Check out Cleure’s Fluoride-Free Toothpaste, a gentle, SLS-free formula ideal for sensitive teeth and gums. Unique from other brands, our toothpaste is recommended by both dentists and dermatologists.

How To Choose the Best Fluoride-Free Toothpaste

When selecting a toothpaste without fluoride, consider the following factors:

Ingredients: Look for dicalcium phosphate, xylitol, or baking soda for added oral health benefits.
Sensitivity: Choose a gentle formula if you have sensitive teeth or gums.
Certifications: While some brands highlight certifications like organic or EWG-verified, these don’t always indicate a safer or better product. At Cleure, we focus on ingredient safety over marketing labels, and all of our products are cruelty-free.
Taste & Texture: Fluoride-free toothpaste comes in different flavors and textures. If you have sensitivities, a flavor-free or mint-free toothpaste may be the best choice to avoid irritation.

Interested in doing some more research to buy your next natural toothpaste? Check out our full guide, What to Look for in Natural Toothpaste.

Is fluoride-free toothpaste effective?

Fluoride-free toothpaste can still be effective if it contains alternative remineralizing agents like dicalcium phosphate and xylitol. Cleure’s fluoride-free toothpaste even comes in a pleasant cinnamon flavor, accommodating those that desire a non-mint toothpaste option while fighting surface stains, tartar, dry mouth, and cavities!

Interested in more ways to fight those pesky surface stains without visiting the dentist? Check out our tips for removing and preventing stains.

Should you switch to fluoride-free toothpaste?

Fluoride-free toothpaste is a great option for those who want a more natural oral care routine, have concerns about fluoride exposure, or prefer alternative cavity protection.

If you’re considering switching, be sure to choose a high-quality toothpaste with proven ingredients. For a safe, effective option, check out Cleure’s fluoride-free toothpaste, designed to support a healthy smile without unnecessary additives.

To support your overall oral health, be sure to maintain a balanced diet. Here are some healthy snack ideas for healthy teeth.

References: